Omer or "counting of the Omer" is the biblical term for the sheaves (grain stalks; wave offering) at the first barley harvest in spring. In addition, the seven-week period between Passover and Pentecost (Shavuot), during which this sacrifice was offered, is also called omer (Lev 23:15-16). The days between Passover and Pentecost are called the "omer days." Today there is no longer a Jerusalem Temple, but nevertheless the 7x7=49 days between Passover (Pesach) and Pentecost (Shavuot) are still counted (see Wikipedia).
Lev 23:15-16: "You shall count seven full weeks [literally: "seven full/complete Sabbaths"; not weeks] from the day after the Sabbath [i.e. the 15th Nisan], from the day [that is, from the 16th of Nisan] that you brought the sheaf [lit.: omer] of the wave offering. 16 You shall count 50 days [7x7=49 +1 = 50 days] to the day after the seventh Sabbath [lit.: the sabbath the seventh]. Then you shall present a grain offering of new grain to the Lord."
The 14th Nisan falls on a Wednesday (4th day of the week) about every third year. If a weekly Sabbath fell on the 14th Nisan, then the Passover lamb was slaughtered the day before (13th Nisan). The counting of Omer (the 7x7=49 days with the 7 Sabbaths until Pentecost) starts from the day after the High Sabbath (15th Nisan). Between the first yearly Sabbath (15th Nisan, Passover) and the third yearly Sabbath (Pentecost) there are always seven weekly Sabbaths. If the 14th Nisan falls on a Wednesday, then the "first Sabbath" (Mark 16:9) is always on the 17th Nisan in the count of the 7 weekly Sabbaths until Pentecost. That was the day on which Jesus rose from the dead. Since the annual Sabbaths fall on different weekdays, the feast of Pentecost can also be on different weekdays. The following table shows the calculation of the 7 Sabbaths between the years 2000 to 2030 according to the Jewish calendar of today:
It is EXTREMELY important that the symbolic connection of the 50 days between the first High Sabbath (Nisan 15, the great feast of the Exodus from Egypt and, of course, Jesus' deliverance from the death penalty) and the Great Jubilee Day (Shavuot, Pentecost) is exactly a Jubilee period (50 days) after that of the deliverance Jesus obtained for us. This connection between the first and the 3rd High Sabbath of the year is spiritually extremely important and must not be postponed, otherwise it will not properly describe the relationship of the Bride to the Bridegroom. Again, it is very important not to change the symbolic Jubilee Feast of Pentecost, exactly 50 days after the first High Sabbath (15th of Nisan), i.e. after the physical and spiritual exodus. Only this perfectly shows the spiritual relationship of the preceding bridegroom with His bride (who follows Him wherever He goes). The day of resurrection (Nisan 17) was never the decisive criterion to calculate the day of Pentecost, because no one could prevent the resurrection of Jesus anymore, just as no one can prevent our resurrection. More important was the physical and spiritual exodus from sin and this was to be celebrated immediately after the death of Jesus, that is, on the 15th of Nisan. Only this was an annual high Sabbath, but not the day of Jesus' resurrection on a small weekly Sabbath (Nisan 17). After Jesus fulfilled His mission, He rose on His day of rest, nothing could fit symbolically better in the overall context. But the counting of the Omer was always done from the first Jubilee day (High Sabbath Passover, Nisan 15) to the next Jubilee day (High Sabbath Pentecost) after exactly 50 days.
At the introduction of the first Passover at the time of Moses and also in the year when Jesus was crucified, the 14th Nisan fell on a Wednesday. The resurrection of Jesus took place after "3 days and 3 nights" "early on the first Sabbath" (Mark 16:9). Between the first annual Sabbath (15th Nisan, Passover) and the third annual Sabbath (Pentecost) there are exactly seven weekly Sabbaths. The date in today's Gregorian calendar can be easily determined. The following table shows the years in the Jewish calendar in which the 14th of Nisan falls on a Wednesday:
Since the Jewish calendar is based on statistical averages, Pentecost always falls on the 6th Siwan (the 3rd month of the year). But in the biblical calendar of God, each month begins with the first visible moon crescent over Jerusalem. Therefore there are years in which Pentecost does not always fall on the 6th Siwan in God's calendar (see calendar).
After the women had rested on the High Sabbath (15th Nisan), the day after the Sabbath they bought the oils to prepare the ointments (Mk 16:1; Lk 23:56a). According to Neh 10:31-32, no goods could be sold on the Sabbath. Therefore, the earliest possible day for shopping was the day after the High Sabbath.
The evangelist Mark makes this very clear, but unfortunately most Christians overlook his important words:
Which Sabbath was meant here? It is of course the High Sabbath (15th Nisan), because the Bible emphasizes that the preceding preparation day (14th Nisan) on which Jesus was crucified was not a normal preparation day for a weekly Sabbath, but a preparation day (definition) for the "High Sabbath" (definition). Since no work was allowed to be done on this High Sabbath, and Jesus was only provisionally embalmed in a hurry on the preparation day, the women had to wait until the day after the High Sabbath to buy and prepare the ointments. This second calendar day after Jesus' death (the day after the High Sabbath) includes the second night and the third day of light on which Jesus was dead or in the "heart of the earth":
It is important to clear up a misunderstanding concerning the time of cutting the first cereal stalks in the field. All the festivals of God were related to the harvest, and the Passover festival was the spring festival where the harvest was first allowed to begin (Leviticus 23:9-21). A sheaf (also called omer) is a bundle of grain stalks with the ears from the first harvest of the early grain (barley). The priests went into the field on the day after the High Sabbath (Nisan 15), that is, on a workday and harvested the sheaf of the firstfruits. The priests solemnly offered these ears of grain as a wave offering to thank God for the first crops (firstfruits). Only after this ceremony could the work in the field begin and the harvest of the early grain (barley) could be started.
There are many sources confirming the Omer cutting from the 16th Nisan onwards (Septuagint, Philon, Flavius Josephus, Jewish and Christian Bible dictionaries). If the 16th Nisan fell on a weekly Sabbath, then according to the Jewish Encyclopedia (Link) only three ears of corn (instead of five) were harvested, the field had to be nearby, and only one person (instead of three) was to cut the barley ears. However, on a weekly Sabbath no remains of the Passover lamb were scented to be burned. This is also confirmed by the Talmud (Seder 2, Mishna Pesachim, chapter VII, verse 10; page 165, translation by Georg Beer, 1912, Digitalsat of the University of Frankfurt, free download). In it there are some explanations: The remains of the Passover lamb were to be burned on the 16th Nisan. However, if the 16th fell on a weekly Sabbath, the remains did not have to be burned until the 17th, so as not to affect either the feast day or the Sabbath. After the scattering of the Jews to all the countries of the earth in 70 AD, the calendar of God was changed by Hillel II in 359 AD in such a way that the 16th Nisan could never fall on a weekly Sabbath. Thus, the firstfruits could always be offered on the 16th of Nisan.
Very ancient Jewish sources repeatedly emphasize the 16th of Nisan (i.e., the day after the High Sabbath) as the first day of the census:
Also, in many European countries where Jews have reported on the harvest seasons in Israel (or Palestine), there has been repeated reference to Nisan 16 as the first day of the barley harvest (or counting of the Omer). A quote from Hermann Vogelstein in 1894 serves as an example:
During the seven days of Passover, no leaven was allowed to be eaten, but work could be done on all days (except on the three Sabbaths during the Passover festival). What is the meaning of this Omer commandment? God did not introduce meaningless rules, but He wanted to reveal His plan with mankind from the beginning: The first ears of grain (grave) of the early grain are symbolic of Jesus, the firstfruit of all who have fallen asleep (1Cor 15:20; Col 1:18). The summer harvest stands for the Christians, the firstfruits (Rom 8:23; 16:5; 1Cor 16:15), who died in the Lord and will participate in the first resurrection. They will rise from the dead at the Rapture. The term omer counting refers to the counting of each of the 49 days (7x7=49) between the biblical feasts of Passover and Pentecost. The Bible reports counting Omer up to the feast of weeks as follows:
When was the first time in the year that the sickle was placed on the grain stalks? That was, of course, on the first working day after the High Sabbath of the year (15th Nisan, Passover), that is, on the 16th Nisan, when the first harvest of the year was allowed and the first yarrow was cut. Thus, this first working day (16th Nisan) is the first day in the count of 49 days with the seven Sabbaths until the 50th day (Pentecost). The first weekly Sabbath, which followed this working day (16th Nisan), was thus clearly the first of seven Sabbaths in the count to Pentecost. It was therefore also briefly called the „first Sabbath“ or „first of the Sabbaths“ (because there are seven Sabbaths). This „first Sabbath“ exists only once a year. It is not only spoken of in the Old Testament, but also the evangelist Mark chooses it in Mark 16:9. It literally says:
„Risen from the dead but early on the first sabbath [πρωτη σαββατου, Sabbath in singular], He [Jesus] appeared first to Mary...".
All Jews and all Christians in the early Christian church knew exactly what was meant by this, because they knew the biblical calendar (see link). Only when the calendar of feast days was changed a few centuries after Christ's death and Sunday was officially prescribed as a weekly holiday binding for all Christians, only then did the knowledge of this „first Sabbath“ fall into oblivion. Only Christians and Jews who are faithful to the Bible have preserved this knowledge over all centuries. They know that there are not only the four Sundays of Advent until Christmas, but since 3,500 years the seven Sabbaths between Passover and Pentecost.
If someone today would ask a Christian what the „first Sabbath“ or the „first of the Sabbaths“ is, he would only get a surprised face in reply. But in the first Christian congregation, the so-called "early church," all people knew this term and knew that the first weekly Sabbath after the annual High Sabbath (Nisan 15) was meant by it, counting from seven weeks to Pentecost. But the sheaf was not cut after this first weekly Sabbath, but already after the High Sabbath. This was a prophetic way of giving thanks from the beginning for the harvest of the firstfruits of Jesus and the forthcoming Ascension to the Father. If someone claims that the omer was offered at the exact same time that Jesus rose from the dead, then this ceremony should have taken place in the dark period of the Sabbath. Harvesting was not allowed on a Sabbath, so the sheaf had to be cut the day before, for all the evangelists unanimously mention the resurrection of Jesus „on a Sabbath“ (Mk 16:2; Lk 24:1; Jh 20:1) just as the day was beginning to dawn (see illustration above). The offering of Omer as a wave offering was intended to indicate the imminent resurrection of Jesus.
Often the statement of Lev 23:11,15-16 and Dt 16:9 is used in order to prove that Jesus rose from the dead on a Sunday and ascended to the Father on a Sunday. Even some churches that keep the Sabbath have been influenced by this thought. Since many Christians are not familiar with the biblical calendar or with the Israeli holiday order, because they pay little attention to the Old Testament, even though it was the foundation of Jesus and the first Christian church, they cannot differentiate between the Sabbaths. They overlook the fact that here God was not speaking of the first day after the normal weekly Sabbath, but of the first day after the High Sabbath, the Passover feast day. There is a big difference. This "day after the Sabbath" does not therefore always mean Sunday, but rather any day of the week. On a Sunday the sheaf cannot have been cut at all, there are several reasons for this:
Some Christians had a problem especially with the verse in Lev 23:16 where "until the day after the seventh sabbath". Literally it says: "until the next/following the Sabbath the seventh you shall number 50 days". So they thought that this must mean the day directly after the seventh weekly Sabbath, that is, a Sunday. But they did not consider that verse 16 in most Bibles was translated inaccurately. For in the context it is about the 50th day after the seventh Sabbath, which can fall on different weekdays from year to year. Besides: the Hebrew "yom" means not only "day" but also "time". This is also how the following time after the seventh Sabbath was understood. The first occurrence of the word "yom" (day, which many add in Lev 23:16) is found for the first time in Gen 2:4: "It was at that day [or time] that the LORD God made the earth and the heavens". Here (and also in other places) the Luther Bible translates the same word with "time". In Leviticus, the emphasis in the calculation of the Feast of Pentecost is on counting exactly fifty days after the high Feast Sabbath (15th Nisan), regardless of which day of the week the 50th day falls. That is why counting is necessary, otherwise it would be superfluous if the Sunday of Pentecost always came out. Then God could have simply spoken of the "first day of the week after seven weeks". So Pentecost would always fall on the same day of the week, not on different days (hence the counting), as is the case in God's calendar. However, it was counted from the 16th Nisan on. Many biblical scholars see this in exactly the same way, and the Jews also count in the same way to this day, and no differently.
Already at the time of Jesus there was a dispute between the Pharisees and the Sadducees (and Karites, Samaritans) about which "day after the sabbath" was meant, from which time on the counting should be done. In contrast to the Pharisees, who always offered the sheaf on the 16th Nisan (i.e. always after the annual Sabbath), for the Sadducees the "day after the Sabbath" was meant the day after the weekly Sabbath. They therefore always celebrated the Omer offering on the first day of the week and thus Pentecost on a Sunday. However, the priests, Jesus and the people did NOT adhere to this small splinter group. They regarded the day after the Sabbath in Lev 23:11 as the first day after the High Passover Sabbath (Nisan 15). This is why they always performed the offering of the Omer on the 16th of Nisan, which falls on different days of the week from year to year, because the 15th of Nisan also falls on different days. The calculation has been used by the Jews for thousands of years and has not changed to this day.
The doctrine of the Sadducee sect must be evaluated with the utmost caution, because they did not believe in angels or in the resurrection (Mt 22:23), so it is not surprising if they also erred in the question of the calculation of the feast day and could not grasp the deep meaning in God's plan. How can someone who does not believe in angels and the resurrection even understand the calendar and the plan of God? That is not possible at all. They would therefore never have been able to understand the connection between the spiritual symbolism of the liberation of the Church of Israel on the High Sabbath of Passover (15 Nisan) and the founding of the New Testament Church on the High Sabbath of Pentecost after exactly 50 days, even though this all happened during their lifetime and in their state of Israel. Jesus himself judged harshly about the ignorance of the Sadducees and He answered them, „You are wrong, because you [the Sadducees] know neither the Scriptures nor the power of God“ (Mt 22:29). This lack of knowledge of the Word of God (the Bible), which Jesus clearly mentioned, was also reflected in their false Omer counting. While the Pharisees were a group of lawful priests who were self-righteous and had little love; on the other hand, they were meticulously accurate and at least had maintained the correct count until Pentecost. Jesus also said that the Pharisees (and not the Sadducees) should sit in Moses' seat and that the people should listen to the Pharisees, including the counting of Omer:
Mt 23:1-3: "Then Jesus said to the crowds and to his disciples, 2 “The scribes and the Pharisees [not the Sadducees] sit on Moses' seat, 3 so do and observe whatever they [the Pharisees] tell you, but not the works they do. For they preach, but do not practice."
Many Christians reject all the teachings of the Sadducees. The only exception is the miscalculation of the omer to get them to the desired Sunday. But Jesus Christ has personally told us which of these two groups we should listen to. He meant the scribes and the Pharisees, but not the Sadducees. Part of "do and observe whatever they tell you" is to keep the correct biblical calendar, which includes the Omer count.
From the time of Joshua (Jos 5:10-12) until the time of Jesus, the High Sabbath was celebrated on the 15th of Nisan and on the 16th of Nisan the counting of Omer began and we cannot find a single Bible passage that says that Jesus complained about it or that he changed the way of counting and thought up Pentecost Sunday.
Another fact that many Christians ignore: Paul himself was a Pharisee, he knew very well that in Israel the counting of omer began from the day after the high Sabbath.
In the book of Acts there is much reported about Paul and never a word is mentioned from which it could be deduced that he would have been against the counting method that was usual in Israel at that time. The wave sacrifice was offered on the 16th of Nisan. It was the day after the high Sabbath and not after a weekly Sabbath. The former Pharisee Paul also wrote 14 epistles and in none of them did he claim that the Jews were not calculating the days correctly or that anything in the calculation should be changed. So it is not surprising that even Flavius Josephus regards the calculation of Paul and the Pharisees in the state of Israel as binding (see below). Paul wrote to the Corinthians:
1Cor 16:8: "But I will stay in Ephesus until Pentecost."
The biblical feast of Pentecost, which falls on different days of the week from year to year, which some Christians describe as Old Testament or "too Jewish" (because they always want a Pentecost Sunday), also existed after the resurrection of Jesus. The New Testament church was founded on this day, and Paul also mentions this day in his letter to the Corinthians. This raises the question: How did he calculate Pentecost? Certainly not the way the Sadducees did and also not the way many Christians do today by following the Pope's calendar (which did not even exist at the time), as Amir Tsarfati does, for example. Paul also did not count like the Church of God or some Messianic Jews, who follow the Omer from a Sunday according to the new Jewish calendar, which was only invented in the 4th century (i.e. long after Paul's death) by rabbis who rejected Jesus as the Messiah. Paul reckoned the 50 days like the Pharisees, i.e. always from the 16th of Nisan. Anyone who disagrees should please prove it to us from biblical and historical sources, which no one has yet succeeded in doing. These people simply quote the biblical passage "day after the Sabbath" and want to persuade the Israelites and us that this supposedly always means the day after Saturday, i.e. Sunday, and not the day after the High Sabbath, which many do not even know. No, today we know exactly how the Pharisees and therefore also Paul calculated the Omer.
Wikipedia also makes clear that until the destruction of the Jerusalem Temple in 70 AD, the omer was always cut on the second day (16th Nisan) of Passover, that is, after the high Sabbath (15th Nisan):
Many Christians wish to have the offering of the omer after a weekly Sabbath, that is, on a Sunday, in order to be able to defend this unbiblical day. The Bible (especially Jesus' own words), the Jewish calendar, and numerous historical sources speak against this, speaking of the day after the annual Sabbath. Another important and clear proof that the Israelites calculated the Omer from the day after the Feast Sabbath, that is, from the 16th Nisan, is given by the Jewish-Roman historian Flavius Josephus (*37; †after 100), who came from the same Jewish people (and even from a family of priests), lived at the same time and in the same geographical area as Jesus and the apostles. He wrote around 94 AD, a work in which he describes the history of the Jewish people. It is especially interesting that he refers to Lev 23:11 and describes exactly from which day the Omer was counted:
„In the month of Xanthicus, which is by us called Nisan, and is the beginning of our year, on the 14th day of the lunar month, when the sun is in Aries, (for in this month it was that we were delivered from bondage under the Egyptians,) the law ordained that we should every year slay that sacrifice which I before told you we slew when we came out of Egypt, and which was called the Passover; and so we do celebrate this passover in companies, leaving nothing of what we sacrifice till the day following. The feast of unleavened bread succeeds that of the passover, and falls on the 15th day of the month, and continues seven days, wherein they feed on unleavened bread; on every one of which days two bulls are killed, and one ram, and seven lambs. Now these lambs are entirely burnt, besides the kid of the goats which is added to all the rest, for sins; for it is intended as a feast for the priest on every one of those days. But on the second day of unleavened bread, which is the 16th day of the month, they first partake of the fruits of the earth, for before that day they do not touch them. And while they suppose it proper to honor God, from whom they obtain this plentiful provision, in the first place, they offer the first-fruits of their barley, and that in the manner following: They take a handful of the ears, and dry them, then beat them small, and purge the barley from the bran; they then bring one tenth deal to the altar, to God; and, casting one handful of it upon the fire, they leave the rest for the use of the priest. And after this it is that they may publicly or privately reap their harvest. They also at this participation of the first-fruits of the earth, sacrifice a lamb, as a burnt-offering to God“ (The Antiquities Of The Jews: 3rd book, chapter 10, v.5, translated from Greek by William Whiston).
The Wikipedias page quotes similarly:
"On the second day of unleavened bread, that is to say the sixteenth, our people partake of the crops which they have reaped and which have not been touched till then, and esteeming it right first to do homage to God, to whom they owe the abundance of these gifts, they offer to him the first-fruits of the barley in the following way. After parching and crushing the little sheaf of ears and purifying the barley for grinding, they bring to the altar an assaron [it was a volumetric measure] for God, and, having flung a handful thereof on the altar, they leave the rest for the use of the priests. Thereafter all are permitted, publicly or individually, to begin harvest" (source).
Like all their fathers through all generations, today's Jews also count the day of Pentecost according to the biblical calendar and begin counting the first day also after the High Passover Sabbath (15th Nisan), that is, on the 16th of Nisan. That this is indeed the case can be proved quickly on the many Internet sites that show the Jewish calendar. Here is an example from the year 2020, in which exactly the same order of days at the Passover existed as in the year in which Jesus was crucified. And also here the calculation starts from the 16th Nisan:
Omer counting thus means the counting of each of the 49 days (7x7=49) between the Jewish feasts of Passover and Shavuot. This period includes a series of seven weekly Sabbaths (see first figure above). The "first Sabbath" of this series was mentioned by the evangelist Mark in Mk 16:9. The 50th day is Shavuot (Pentecost).
Since the 16th Nisan (as the first day of Omer counting) can fall on different days of the week, the biblical Pentecost also falls on different days of the week. Some Christians have an arrogant or even anti-Semitic attitude and think that the Jews are wrong in the calendar. But the Jews are much better versed in this than the Christians, who prefer to listen to the Pope and who has introduced a catholic calendar that has nothing more to do with the biblical calendar. Jesus said "salvation is from the Jews" (Jn 4:22). Therefore, Christians should also look at the Biblical holidays, at least in their symbolism, because most of the so-called Christian holidays are in reality nothing more than un-Biblical and ancient pagan holidays of the Lord Sol (Sun god, bringer of light) and the heavenly goddess Astarte, which were merely decorated with Christian elements. When the Holy Spirit was poured out at Pentecost, this did not happen on the day according to the Pope's calendar, but according to the biblical calendar.
Below are the two compared examples from the years 2000 and 2020, in which the 14th Nisan fell on a Wednesday, the 15th Nisan on a Thursday and the "first Sabbath" or "first of the Sabbaths" on a 17th Nisan. The dark blue fields show the three Sabbaths of the year (15th, 21st Nisan and Pentecost). On the right side the 7 weekly Sabbaths until Pentecost are listed. The numbers marked in green show the conting of the Omer, i.e. the 49+1=50 days:
The two tables show the counting of the seven weekly Sabbaths up to Pentecost in the Jewish calendar 2000 and 2020 according to Hillel. This shows which day of the week the feast Sabbaths fall on. The areas marked in green show the first day of the counting of the Omer and therefore also the 7th, 14th, 21st and 49th days. The "first Sabbath" of the 7 weekly Sabbaths up to Pentecost can fall at the beginning, middle or end of the Passover week. This means that the High Sabbath of Pentecost also falls on different days of the week. In the biblical calendar, Passover 2000 was celebrated a month earlier, and in 2020 and 2023 the biblical and Jewish calendars fell on the same days.
When the Holy Spirit was poured out at Pentecost, this did not happen on the day according to the Pope's calendar, but also according to God's biblical calendar. And anyone expecting the Rapture and return of Jesus on a specific biblical feast day must of course be guided by the biblical (divine) calendar and not the Catholic calendar. But it does not necessarily have to be the case that the Rapture has to take place on a biblical feast day, for we do not know when God will finish the spiritual harvest of the first fruits and when the last Christian is called to be the spiritual bride of Christ.
On April 8, 2020, the preparation day of the 14th Nisan fell again to a Wednesday. So every Christian could experience exactly the same sequence of days as in the year when Jesus was crucified. The first omer (16th Nisan) was again counted from the day after the High Sabbath (15th Nisan), as it has always been (see calendar illustration above).
Under the keywords "Jewish calendar" there are many websites in which the counting of the Feast of Weeks is given with exact dates. The top image on this website shows the Omer count for the years 2000 to 2030 The years 2000, 2002, 2003, 2006, 2020, 2023, 2026, 2027 and 2030 have exactly the same order of feast days as the year in which Jesus was executed. You can recognize the first three major annual Sabbaths (1st and 7th day of Passover and Pentecost; dark blue fields) and the 7 minor Sabbaths (light blue fields) in between.
According to the Jewish calendar, Omer counting ALWAYS begins "on the day after the [High Feast] Sabbath" (15th Nisan), that is, on the 16th of Nisan (first day of Omer counting) and includes the seven weekly Sabbaths until the "Feast of Weeks" (Pentecost, the 50th day). So the phrase "on the first of the Sabbaths" or "on the first Sabbath" (Mark 16:9) never meant "on the first day of the week" or "on the first of the Sundays" or even "on a Sunday", but always only the first of the seven (7) Sabbaths between Passover (15th Nisan) and Pentecost, all of which have an exact date. Pentecost can fall on a Sunday according to God's calendar, but it does not have to; this is rarely the case. In 2023, the biblical and Jewish calendars for Passover fell on the same days, so the calculation can be displayed in any online Jewish calendar. The Israelites were not mistaken, but many Christians are mistaken because they desperately want Pentecost Sunday and therefore have to falsify God's calendar.
In conclusion, it must be emphasized that for our question of the day on which Jesus rose from the dead, it is unimportant from when the Omer counting begins. For it is clearly documented in the Bible that after the great Sabbath there followed a workday, which was followed by the weekly Sabbath on which the women came to the tomb. This weekly Sabbath is, in any case and without doubt, the first Sabbath after the Passover Sabbath, no matter when someone starts counting Omer. The offering of Omer was an indication of the imminent (and not the past) resurrection and ascension of Jesus! So this ceremony was also perfectly fulfilled at the next possible time.
Unfortunately, there are many Christians and even Messianic Jews who misstate the feast of Pentecost and often speak several times of a "true Pentecost", which they postpone again and again (sometimes even several times in one year). They claim that the Jews themselves are allegedly not able to calculate their own feast days correctly and need Christians to present them with new feast day calculations every year. No, certainly not. The Isarelites have always calculated their Pentecost correctly. The information shown here in our video and on the website does not contradict the calendar of the Jews. The only difference is that they still do not currently use God's biblical calendar, but rather the calendar of the Patriarch Hillel, which was developed in the 4th century AD and is based only on inaccurate statistical averages because the Jews, who were scattered around the world after 70 AD, could no longer see the first crescent moon over Jerusalem and thus could not accurately determine the beginnings of the months. But the way they count the feast days is correct and is even confirmed by Flavius Josephus. In the year 2020 the calendar of God and the Jewish calendar of Hillel fell on the same feast days of Passover, thus there was also the feast of Pentecost on the same day of the week. Any Christian can see the 7 Sabbaths between Passover (15th of Nisan) and Pentecost (50th day after the first High Sabbath) in any Jewish calendar. The Israelites always begin counting the Omer (as their fathers always did) from the day after the first annual High Sabbath, that is, from the 16th of Nisan. This is extremely important because it is the only way to maintain the direct connection between the first festival (Exodus from Egypt and deliverance from sin and death penalty by Jesus) to the Jubilee period of 50 days (Pentecost) after that first High Sabbath. But if counting starts from Sunday, then the connection to the first High Sabbath is destroyed. Many Christians absolutely wish the unbiblical resurrection of Jesus on a Sunday, therefore they delete 6 Sabbaths in the Greek NT (see Interlinear) and replace them 6 times by Sunday. Therefore, they miscalculate Pentecost and start counting the Omer, not after the first High Sabbath, but after the first weekly Sabbath, that is, from Sunday. They make the Catholic Easter Sunday the new festive Sabbath "First Fruits" to one of the 7 Annual Feasts of God, and for this they erase the 7th Annual Sabbath Shemini Atzeret (Last Great Day of Assembly), so as to come back to the number 7. These Christians want Resurrection Sunday and Pentecost Sunday and prefer to follow the Pope's calendar, but not God's biblical calendar.
Even numerous Messianic Jews (or Messianic Christians) have fallen into this trap and thus support the teachings of the Pope and his Catholic Church. Among them is the well-known preacher Amir Tsarfati from Israel. He too defends the Catholic Resurrection Sunday, miscalculates the Israeli feast days and denies the sign of the Messiah (3 days and 3 nights). E-mails were answered by his team with unfriendly comments. It hurts us very much to see how attempts are made to lead the church ("Bride of Christ") to false feasts. Therefore, we must not be silent here, but have a responsibility according to Ezek 3:17-21, 1Th 5:19-21 and Eph 5:11. The Messianic Jews do not want Jesus to be resurrected on a Sabbath, because they think that they would then be obligated to keep the Sabbath like the Jews. That is why they wish Jesus to be resurrected on a Sunday (see First Fruits, Amir Tsarfati's First Fruits Sunday), because otherwise there would be nothing at all in favor of their Sunday meetings and otherwise they would not come to their Pentecost Sunday. In reality, it is exactly the opposite, because what many overlook: It was only through the resurrection of Jesus on his day that he fulfilled the Sabbath commandment in full and became our Sabbath rest. But Amir Tsarfati and many free-church congregations prefer to spread Catholic teachings. To avoid misunderstanding, we are saved by the blood of Jesus, not by keeping days, but that is precisely why we must not change the timing and calendar of God.
Hes 3:17-21: „Son of man, I have made you a watchman for the house of Israel. Whenever you hear a word from my mouth, you shall give them warning from me. 18 If I say to the wicked, ‘You shall surely die,’ and you give him no warning, nor speak to warn the wicked from his wicked way, in order to save his life, that wicked person shall die for[d] his iniquity, but his blood I will require at your hand. 19 But if you warn the wicked, and he does not turn from his wickedness, or from his wicked way, he shall die for his iniquity, but you will have delivered your soul. 20 Again, if a righteous person turns from his righteousness and commits injustice, and I lay a stumbling block before him, he shall die. Because you have not warned him, he shall die for his sin, and his righteous deeds that he has done shall not be remembered, but his blood I will require at your hand. 21 But if you warn the righteous person not to sin, and he does not sin, he shall surely live, because he took warning, and you will have delivered your soul.“
1Thess 5:21-22: „Prove all things; hold fast that which is good. Abstain from all appearance of evil.“
Epheser 5:11: „Take no part in the unfruitful works of darkness, but instead expose them.“
The turbo resurrection of Jesus that many theologians wanted never happened, but rather he fulfilled the sign of the Messiah (3 days and 3 nights):
None of this is difficult to understand. The Jews know that at the time of the Exodus, the 10th of Nisan fell on a Sabbath (Shabbat ha-Gadol), the 14th of Nisan on a Wednesday and the 15th of Nisan on a Thursday. And we too have experienced the same sequence of days in numerous years as in the year in which our Lord was crucified:
On You Tube, various Christians publish completely new calculations of the Omer, which the world has never seen before. They calculate 99, 100 or even 102 days. Some have seen special star constellations and would like Pentecost to move on this day and calculate 50+50+x days. We published a comment on these channels, which was deleted by the channel operator after a short time, because other Christians evaluated this contribution positively and rejected these new calculations. As these people have no arguments, and cannot refute us, they simply delete all critical messages, so that the church (the Bride of Christ) is put on a wrong calculation. In contrast to this, we are not at all afraid of communicating with biblical passages, and do not run away, so here is the text again:
QUOTE: It is really sad to see, how some Christians are twisting the Word of God to create a new private Pentecost date that has not existed for 3,500 years and is confusing the Bride of Christ. It is a real PAIN to hear how some old familiar verses are twisted. Not a single verse could confirm this new theory, NONE. And it is a great insult to all Jews, who allegedly would not be able to understand their own language (the Hebrew mother tongue) and would need Christians to set up completely new dates and rules of the feasts for them. Terrible. The word "Pentecost" is biblical and is written three times in the NT, this word was used by God (!!!) and it means 50, not 99, 100 or 102 or 50+x days. There is only one "true Pentecost" but many "fake Pentecost" calculated by Christians.
Such new private Pentecost that never has been and never will be accepted in Israel. When God speaks of 50 days and 7 Sabbaths, He means it and does not mean 99 days or 102 days and 14 or 15 Sabbaths. You are destroying the numerical meaning of the Bible with 7x7=49+1=50 days. This is the same order as the calculation of the Jubilee years, Pentecost is also a kind of Jubilee day, because on this day the Holy Spirit was poured out and the Church was founded. Thus began the age of the church and of grace and the rapture will end this era. On the day of Pentecost the Holy Spirit came from heaven to earth; but at the Rapture the Holy Spirit goes from earth to heaven. Only God knows when the spiritual harvest of the first fruits will be completed. But Christians who are watching will NOT be surprised. The meaning of numbers (especially 50 and 7) is extremely important. Pentecost means the 50th day after the first high Sabbath of the year on the 15th of Nisan (Passover). This is the most important day, because on this day was the Exodus from Egypt and on this day we remember our salvation through the blood of Jesus Christ.
In 2020 the calculation very simple because God's astronomical calendar (first visible crescent of the moon determines the beginning of the month) falls on the same day on the 1st of Nisan as the mathematical Jewish calendar of Hillel. Thus, the 14th Nisan and the 15th Nisan (High Sabbath, Passover) and the "first Sabbath" (17th Nisan) of a series of seven weekly Sabbaths also fell on the same day. Jesus died on the 14th Nisan and He rose from the death "early on the first Sabbath" (17th Nisan, Mk 16:9, i.e. the first of the seven Sabbaths to Pentecost) so Jesus gave the answer how we should calculate PENTECOST (50) and the seven Sabbaths (and the "first Sabbath").
The first Christian church calculated Pentecost in the same way as the Hebrews did. Omer is to be counted from the day after the High Sabbath, just as the Jews do today. There is much evidence of this in the Bible and even in extra-biblical literature:
One reply with a silly answer with which some pastors defend these new omer countings:
"In Acts chapter 2 the Apostles were accused of being drunk on new wine. The grape harvest in Israel is not until late July early August."
Our answer:
With this one verse you want to postpone the 50th day (Pentecost) of God to 99, 100 or 102 days and ignore all other Bible verses? No, there has always been wine in Israel throughout the year. Jesus himself said that we should put new wine into new wineskins (Mt 9:17). He said: "But new wine must be put into new bottles [literally: wineskins]; and both are preserved. 39 No man also having drunk OLD wine straightway desireth new: for he saith, The OLD is better" (Lk 5:38-39, KJV). We ourselves come from a wine-producing family and know exactly what "young wine" or "new wine" are and what they are not. In Israel there was always wine and the old one was the best and most expensive. You can be drunk all year round, but you can't ignore all the other important Bible verses all year round unless you are drunk. Apparently you have never read that Jesus and the disciples drank wine at the Last Supper (in the first month of Nisan)? Did they just harvest this grapes and made a fresh wine? No. Already at the Passover feast (spring) wine must be drunk, as Lev 23:13 proves. This was either an expensive old wine of good quality or a cheap new (young) wine from the last autumn harvest. In other words: If new wine was drunk at Pentecost, it was from the last harvest in autumn, just like the wine that was drunk before at Passover. We do not know whether Jesus and the apostles drank a "young wine" of the last harvest or an "old wine" of several years. But we do know that in Israel "young wine" has always been drunk in the spring, not only at Pentecost (at the beginning of the summer). A postponement of Pentecost would also change the symbolic meaning of the harvest times in God's plan with the spiritual first fruits (the church of God). This aspect is much more important and has nothing to do with the main harvest time of wine in autumn.
The first grapes are harvested in Israel already at the beginning of the month of Siwan (third month). This is no secret, because they are part of the festival ceremony on Pentecost. For this you do not need to postpone the ancient holy day of the Jews by another 50 days. They are early varieties of grapes for food, which are not suitable for wine production. Therefore no wine was made from these grapes. The harvest of the first ripe grapes always began only from the feast day of Tu B'Av (see calendar) on the 15th day of the 5th month (which was the end of the Pentecost season and the end of the wheat harvest, first fruits), when the virgins went to the vineyards to look for a bridegroom and danced on the night of the full moon (see Rapture Pentecost 2021). However, even if the disciples were to make wine from these new grapes, it is still no reason to postpone Pentecost and to brake the laws of God, which were described in the Torah. Hebrew is the mother tongue of the Jews and they understand better than many Christians what the text in Lev 23 means. They do not need Christians who want to postpone their "Feast of Weeks" (Shavuot, Pentecost). And if the fermentation is not yet sufficiently advanced, then it is not possible to be drunk. Young wine is still present during Pentecost since the last harvest, as well as old wine from previous years. Even if someone translates Acts 2:13 not with "sweet wine" (the word is derived from glucus, cf. glucose) but with "young wine", it is no problem at all. "Young wine" is wine from the last or at most the second-last production. The EU wine market organisation defines it as follows: "Young wine: wine whose alcoholic fermentation has not yet finished and which has not yet been separated from its lees." The longer the fermentation lasts, the more sugar is converted; the result is then a "dry wine".
The grapes suitable for wine production were harvested in Israel around the time of the Feast of Tabernacles (Sukkot), that is, in September/October. Yes, the Bible answers us itself when the grape harvest was in Israel: "Thou shalt observe the feast of tabernacles seven days, after that thou hast gathered in thy corn and thy wine [literally: winepress]" (Dt 16:13). Sukkot was the period when grapes were pressed for wine production.
An exapmple from Europe is the Beaujolais Nouveau (Primeur), an early wine from the French Beaujolais wine region (Lyon). "The grapes are harvested between late August and early September. It is fermented for just a few days and released to the public on the third Thursday of November - "Beaujolais Nouveau Day". It is the first French wine to be released for each vintage year" (Wikipedia).
In professional circles, the "young wine" of the last harvest season is tasted in winter, spring and summer. It is still called "young wine" because the fermentation process is not yet fully completed. With increasing age, the quality also increases. That's why most people prefer to drink old wines, which are more expensive than young wines that are not yet mature. The new wine from the last autumn harvest is also called "young wine" at trade fairs in spring and summer. An additional quote from a wine book:
"Every year in SPRING, the wine scene eagerly awaits the "new" vintage to comment on the results achieved by the weather of the previous year and the winemakers. The wines are then naturally "young" and have just slipped from tank or barrel into the bottle. Wine trends are identified and forecasts are made about the development of the vintage".
However, the one Bible verse in Acts 2:13 can by no means be misused to postpone Pentecost from 50 days to 102 or more days after Passover. This is confirmed by many other Bible verses on the same subject, which have already been shown above.
There are 3 harvest seasons in Israel that are related to the feast days of God. They also have symbolic meaning to the spiritual harvest of the people in God's 7,000 year plan. Those who do not realize this properly will never know the difference in God's plan that God makes between the firstfruits (the Bride of Christ) and other people, because there are different resurrection seasons. The passover season belongs to the first fruit Jesus (barley sheaf), the Pentecost season belongs to the firstfruits (grain, wheat) and has nothing to do with the harvest of the autumn fruits (grapes, fruits) that follows later:
The barley harvest lasted from Passover to Pentecost.
The wheat harvest lasted from Pentecost to Tu'B'Aw.
The grape harvest lasted from Tu'B'Aw to Yom Kippur (Day of Atonement).
It is important to recognize the distinctions God makes in God's plan and not to change His times and His Calendar.
"Prove all things; hold fast that which is good. Abstain from all appearance of evil"
(1Thess 5:21-22)
"Take no part in the unfruitful works of darkness, but instead expose them"
(Epheser 5:11)